Just so I can remember and refer back…
Southwest
IND-MCO: 8:25-11:35 am $168.40-ish
MCO-IND: 1:40-3:00 pm $168.40-ish
NOTE: Southwest will be adding flights from RSW soon…
ATA
IND-MCO: 9:25-11:32 am $222.40
RSW-IND: 8:35-11:05 pm $212.40
AirTran
IND-MCO: 7:00-11:24 am $179.80 (w/ATL layover)
RSW-IND: 3:00-5:30 pm $280.40